Actions

Difference between revisions of "Freescan Bugs and Issues"

From The RadioReference Wiki

m
m
 
(18 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 5: Line 5:
 
   <p>
 
   <p>
 
     View the issues currently being tracked and their status on '''[https://github.com/mfcallahan/FreeSCAN/issues/ GitHub]'''.
 
     View the issues currently being tracked and their status on '''[https://github.com/mfcallahan/FreeSCAN/issues/ GitHub]'''.
−
  </p>
+
</p>
 +
Developers website for freescan - '''http://free-scan.net/
 +
<p>
 +
</p>
 +
'''[https://forums.radioreference.com/threads/freescan-open-source-project-developers-wanted.391866/ Radioreference forum for this project.]
 
</div>
 
</div>
−
 
  
 
* '''Issue: The trunk system warnings when using the RRDB import function are outdated'''
 
* '''Issue: The trunk system warnings when using the RRDB import function are outdated'''
 
**if you try to import a system with a type that isn't supported, you will get a warning message, but the import will still continue. Note that Freescan may currently not have the capability to check for NXDN or DMR/MOTOTRBO systems but these should be warned as well as ProVoice (which it currently does issue a warning). The P2 scanners are the only ones that can handle these system types with the proper firmware upgrades.
 
**if you try to import a system with a type that isn't supported, you will get a warning message, but the import will still continue. Note that Freescan may currently not have the capability to check for NXDN or DMR/MOTOTRBO systems but these should be warned as well as ProVoice (which it currently does issue a warning). The P2 scanners are the only ones that can handle these system types with the proper firmware upgrades.
 
***Suggestion: If a P2 scanner is not being used to load the above 3 modes, issue a warning and send the user either to the RRDB conventional import (with the frequencies loaded), or load these frequencies into EZ-Grab. Either one will allow the user to configure the system the way they want.
 
***Suggestion: If a P2 scanner is not being used to load the above 3 modes, issue a warning and send the user either to the RRDB conventional import (with the frequencies loaded), or load these frequencies into EZ-Grab. Either one will allow the user to configure the system the way they want.
 +
***System Types and Examples
 +
****{{DB|s|8697|DMR Type 3}}
 +
****{{DB|s|2672|EDACS ProVoice}}
 +
****{{DB|s|8511|Hytera XPT}}
 +
****{{DB|s|9601|MOTOTRBO Capacity Plus Single Site}}
 +
****{{DB|s|8856|MOTOTRBO Capacity Plus Multi Site}}
 +
****{{DB|s|7676|MOTOTRBO Connect Plus}}
 +
****{{DB|s|9090|NXDN IDAS Icom Type D}}
 +
****{{DB|s|8108|NXDN NEXEDGE 4800}}
 +
****{{DB|s|9409|NXDN NEXEDGE 9600}}
 +
 +
 +
* '''Issue: Freescan needs to support DMR and NXDN Conventional frequencies found, for example, in the RRDB'''
 +
** Examples:
 +
***[https://www.radioreference.com/apps/db/?ctid=1190 DMR Conventional]
 +
***{{DB|s|9602|DMR Conventional Networked}}
 +
***[https://www.radioreference.com/apps/db/?ctid=35 NXDN Conventional]
  
  
 
* '''Issue: Various import functions allow downloading of frequencies and systems that are not trackable or scannable'''
 
* '''Issue: Various import functions allow downloading of frequencies and systems that are not trackable or scannable'''
−
**No scanner can handle D-Star or Yaesu Fusion. Frequencies like these can be imported (using the EZ Grab function, or the RRDB conventional import) from the amateur radio side of the database, or from other websites. Examples of D-Star listings can be found [https://www.radioreference.com/apps/db/?ctid=1775&tab=ham here]. An example of a Fusion repeater can be viewed [https://www.radioreference.com/apps/db/?ctid=1204&tab=ham here] under mode '''YSF'''. Perhaps they can be programmed but locked out so they can't be scanned.
+
**In cases where a trunk system type is untrackable (i.e. Open Sky, iDen) Freescan issues a warning but allows the import to continue. In such cases, the import should terminate with a warning, as these protocols can't be tracked or decoded.
−
**In cases where a trunk system type is untrackable (i.e. {{DB|s|2101|Open Sky}}), Freescan issues a warning but allows the import to continue. In such cases, a warning message should be followed by an additional warning that the import is discontinued. Open Sky is a protocol that can't be decoded by any hobby level software such as Unitrunker or DSD.  
+
***Examples
−
**In cases where a trunk system type can't be trunked, but it can be scanned conventionally, Freescan will issue a warning, but still try to build a trunked system for it. These types include {{DB|s|4679|LTR Multinet}}, {{DB|s|7903|LTR-Passport}}, {{DB|s|7636|MPT-1327}} and {{DB|s|8052|TETRA}}.
+
****{{DB|s|2101|Open Sky}}
 +
****{{DB|s|5354|iDen Standard}}
 +
****{{DB|s|5742|iDen Harmony}}
 +
**In cases where a trunk system type can't be trunked, but it can be scanned conventionally, Freescan will issue a warning, but still try to build a trunked system for it. These types include LTR Multinet, LTR-Passport, MPT-1327 and TETRA.
 
***Suggestion: In these cases, issue a warning and send the user either to the RRDB conventional import (with the frequencies loaded), or load these frequencies into EZ-Grab. Either one will allow the user to configure the system the way they want.
 
***Suggestion: In these cases, issue a warning and send the user either to the RRDB conventional import (with the frequencies loaded), or load these frequencies into EZ-Grab. Either one will allow the user to configure the system the way they want.
−
**In the amateur radio database, it's quite possible to run into listings for USB or LSB such as found on this [https://www.radioreference.com/apps/db/?ctid=1775&tab=ham page]. Not even the now-discontinued BR330 could handle this mode, so these frequencies should be dropped from the import with a warning.  
+
***Examples
 +
****{{DB|s|4679|LTR Multinet}}
 +
****{{DB|s|7903|LTR-Passport}}
 +
****{{DB|s|7636|MPT-1327}}
 +
****{{DB|s|8052|TETRA}}
 +
 
 +
 
 +
* '''Freescan doesnt recognize amateur radio (ham) modes that scanners cant decode'''
 +
**These should be blocked or locked out using the RRDB conventional import or EZ-Grab.
 +
**No scanner can handle D-Star or Yaesu Fusion. These modes should be rejected.
 +
***Examples
 +
****[https://www.radioreference.com/apps/db/?ctid=1775&tab=ham Cape May County Amateur Radio]  See the entries marked '''D-STAR''' in the mode column
 +
****[https://www.radioreference.com/apps/db/?ctid=1204&tab=ham Prince Georges County Maryland Amateur Radio]  See the entry marked '''YSF''' in the mode column
 +
**There are listings for USB or LSB modes. No scanner can demodulate sideband.
 +
***Example
 +
****[https://www.radioreference.com/apps/db/?ctid=1775&tab=ham Cape May County Amateur Radio] See the entry marked '''USB''' in the mode column
 +
**Frequencies in AM mode below 25 Mhz are only compatible with the BR330T
 +
***Example
 +
****[https://www.radioreference.com/apps/db/?ctid=344&tab=ham Hillsborough County Sheriff's Tactical Amateur Radio Club (STARC)] 
 +
**** See the 14.282 Mhz entry
 +
**Frequencies marked '''Telm''' in the mode column should be locked out.
 +
***Example
 +
****[https://www.radioreference.com/apps/db/?ctid=1191&tab=ham Baltimore County (Maryland) - Amateur Radio]
 +
 
 +
 
 +
'''FreeScan will issue a warning about using a special table for loading a P25 system when it isn't needed'''
 +
* This is a long standing bug that confuses a lot of people. A true P25 system carries all the information it needs in the control channel, so this message is erroneous
  
  
−
* '''FreeScan will issue a warning about using a special table for loading a P25 system when it isn't needed'''
+
'''When there is a change made of any kind, if you go to open a new file it usually happens about 1/2 the time go to close it or open a file, it won't open a pop up asking to save changes. Other 1/2 the time is if you just open a file and don't do anything, go to close it or open a file, it will ask to save changes when there were no changes made.'''
−
** This is a long standing bug that confuses a lot of people. A true P25 system carries all the information it needs in the control channel, so this message is erroneous
 
  
  
−
* '''When there is a change made of any kind, if you go to open a new file it usually happens about 1/2 the time go to close it or open a file, it won't open a pop up asking to save changes. Other 1/2 the time is if you just open a file and don't do anything, go to close it or open a file, it will ask to save changes when there were no changes made.
+
'''When programming at least seen in 396T's that dont have the capability to utilize priority on any trunked radio type, the priority will be sent to the radio. It shows as a P on the display, but wont function as priority.'''
  
  
 +
'''Have a user option under 'Edit' and 'Preferences', a checkbox to have the ability to always open and save to a folder of your choice. If you open or save to another folder, the next time its used, it will look back at the last folder that was used instead.'''
  
  
 +
'''The Canadian SAME codes link is incorrect. Change it to https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/services/weatheradio/specific-area-message-encoding/forecast-regions.html
  
  
 +
'''The noaa same link needs to be changed to https://www.weather.gov/nwr/counties
  
  
 +
'''New trunked system defaults to ID Search, should be ID Scan
  
  
 +
'''Add ability to sort by clicking on say frequency, display, talkgroup, etc. headers
  
  
 +
'''Look at the mostly cosmetic updates under my name their of Ronski - https://web.archive.org/web/20180614024226/http://scannow.org/forum/index.php?topic=1379.0 and at https://forums.radioreference.com/threads/freescan-open-source-project-developers-wanted.391866/page-2#post-3164573
  
  

Latest revision as of 15:25, 8 January 2020

This page will be utilized to capture bugs and issues in the latest beta of FreeScan to support development in an open source environment. Feel free to add snapshots and any other data that will explain how to recreate the bug. The more detail that is provided, the more precise the solution

View the issues currently being tracked and their status on GitHub.

Developers website for freescan - http://free-scan.net/

Radioreference forum for this project.

  • Issue: The trunk system warnings when using the RRDB import function are outdated
    • if you try to import a system with a type that isn't supported, you will get a warning message, but the import will still continue. Note that Freescan may currently not have the capability to check for NXDN or DMR/MOTOTRBO systems but these should be warned as well as ProVoice (which it currently does issue a warning). The P2 scanners are the only ones that can handle these system types with the proper firmware upgrades.



  • Issue: Various import functions allow downloading of frequencies and systems that are not trackable or scannable
    • In cases where a trunk system type is untrackable (i.e. Open Sky, iDen) Freescan issues a warning but allows the import to continue. In such cases, the import should terminate with a warning, as these protocols can't be tracked or decoded.
    • In cases where a trunk system type can't be trunked, but it can be scanned conventionally, Freescan will issue a warning, but still try to build a trunked system for it. These types include LTR Multinet, LTR-Passport, MPT-1327 and TETRA.
      • Suggestion: In these cases, issue a warning and send the user either to the RRDB conventional import (with the frequencies loaded), or load these frequencies into EZ-Grab. Either one will allow the user to configure the system the way they want.
      • Examples



FreeScan will issue a warning about using a special table for loading a P25 system when it isn't needed

  • This is a long standing bug that confuses a lot of people. A true P25 system carries all the information it needs in the control channel, so this message is erroneous


When there is a change made of any kind, if you go to open a new file it usually happens about 1/2 the time go to close it or open a file, it won't open a pop up asking to save changes. Other 1/2 the time is if you just open a file and don't do anything, go to close it or open a file, it will ask to save changes when there were no changes made.


When programming at least seen in 396T's that dont have the capability to utilize priority on any trunked radio type, the priority will be sent to the radio. It shows as a P on the display, but wont function as priority.


Have a user option under 'Edit' and 'Preferences', a checkbox to have the ability to always open and save to a folder of your choice. If you open or save to another folder, the next time its used, it will look back at the last folder that was used instead.


The Canadian SAME codes link is incorrect. Change it to https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/services/weatheradio/specific-area-message-encoding/forecast-regions.html


The noaa same link needs to be changed to https://www.weather.gov/nwr/counties


New trunked system defaults to ID Search, should be ID Scan


Add ability to sort by clicking on say frequency, display, talkgroup, etc. headers


Look at the mostly cosmetic updates under my name their of Ronski - https://web.archive.org/web/20180614024226/http://scannow.org/forum/index.php?topic=1379.0 and at https://forums.radioreference.com/threads/freescan-open-source-project-developers-wanted.391866/page-2#post-3164573

Retrieved from "https://wiki.radioreference.com/index.php?title=Freescan_Bugs_and_Issues&oldid=263053"